The Karen Read Trail: The Murder of John O'Keefe

On January 29, 2022, Boston police officer John O’Keefe was found unresponsive in the snow outside a home in Canton, Massachusetts. He had suffered severe head trauma and was later pronounced dead at the hospital. His girlfriend, Karen Read, was charged with second-degree murder, accused of backing into him with her SUV and leaving him in the freezing cold. The couple had been out drinking the night before, and investigators claimed a fight led to the deadly incident. From the beginning, however, questions were raised about what really happened that night — and whether Karen Read was being wrongly accused.

This case has dominated headlines due to claims of corruption, cover-ups, and conflicts of interest involving law enforcement and the local justice system. What makes it especially explosive is the number of other individuals who were inside the house where O’Keefe was allegedly dropped off — people with deep connections to the police and the district attorney’s office. Read’s defense suggests a broader conspiracy to protect those individuals and shift the blame onto her.
Here are several key figures that continue to fuel speculation and doubt:

Brian Albert – Homeowner and Boston PD officer; John O’Keefe was last seen being dropped off at his house.
Chris Albert – Brian’s brother and a Canton official; alleged to have been at the house that night.
Brian Higgins - a federal law enforcement officer and alleged former fling of Karen Read, was present at the after-hours party.
Jennifer McCabe – Friend of Read who made a questionable Google search: “Hos long to die in the cold?” hours before O’Keefe was found.
Kerry Roberts – Present at the gathering, known to be part of the close-knit social circle involved.
Michael Proctor - The lead investigator who mishandled evidence, wrote crude texts about the suspect and was later fired due to his lack on integrity in this case.

🕵️ Popular Theories Surrounding the Case

The public has split into two major camps: those who believe Karen Read is guilty — and those who believe she’s being framed. Some argue she was intoxicated and accidentally hit O’Keefe, while others believe he never left the house alive and that his body was staged outside.

🧠 My Theory: What I Think Happened That Night.

Here’s my personal theory on what happened to John O’Keefe — a version that considers the evidence, the timeline, and the human dynamics that play into this case.

I believe Karen Read and John O’Keefe had a fairly typical relationship. They loved each other, but like most couples, had their share of insecurities and bumps along the way. On the night of January 28, 2022, they went out drinking and were later invited to an after-bar party. Karen drove them to the house on Fairview Road, but she felt uneasy about going in — she knew Brian Higgins, someone she’d recently had a brief affair with, was inside… awkward. She asked John to go to the door first to make sure they were both welcome. While maneuvering the car to make room for others to park behind her, she lost sight of where John went. He didn’t answer her calls, and he never returned to the car. Feeling ditched, she drove home alone. At 12:36 a.m., her phone connected to John's home Wi-Fi, confirming her return.

This is where my theory changes from others. I believe John dropped — or was separated from — his phone after locking it for the last time, possibly in the yard. The snow could have obscured it, or someone could have thrown it (not sure how apple health data would report this) Inside the house, I think John was confronted, first about why Karen didn’t come in and— perhaps about Karen’s affair — and a fight broke out. He may have been punched in the face (explaining the gash above his eye) and attacked by a dog ( explains wounds on arm) then he was tackled to the ground. While attempting to get up, he became sick and vomited on himself (which aligns with vomit found in his clothing). A second blow could have caused the significant swelling around his eyes and a head injury from hitting an object as he fell backward. I believe those present panicked — and instead of helping — left him incapacitated while scrambling for a story. Evidence suggests minimal blood in the yard, implying he was moved. His phone was called multiple times and I believe they cleaned him up, placed him in a Ford Edge, then drove him to where they found his phone and placed him on top of it. His back pocket was ripped indicating he could have been carried with it. But he was too far gone to call for help.

What supports this theory? For one, no partygoers or the snowplow driver saw a body at the flagpole before 2:30 a.m., meaning John was likely placed there later. A Google search for “hos long to die in the cold” was made around this time — a detail that seems less about saving him and more about creating a believable narrative. If you didn’t know when someone went outside, that information would be meaningless unless you were trying to justify cold exposure as a cause of death.

And finally, let’s talk about the car. There is no credible physical evidence that Karen hit John with her SUV. His body had no bruises, no broken bones, no dislocations to indicate a 6000 lb SUV hit him at 24 mph. Her tail light was still functioning at 5:00 a.m. when she backed into another vehicle, and initial reports of it being shattered were false. The light diffusers were still intact at that point (meaning it still lit up) and experts confirmed the collision damage didn’t match the type of impact that would’ve caused fatal injuries. In short: a hit-and-run never happened.

What do you think happened to John O’Keefe?
Join the conversation by following our weekly updates as we unravel the twists and testimonies from this ongoing trial.