Frequently Asked Questions

How Do Murder Mystery Boxes Work?

Our murder mystery boxes are designed to drop you straight into the role of a detective. Each box contains realistic evidence, case files, suspect profiles, and immersive clues that let you unravel the case. step-by-step. You'll piece together timelines, uncover motives, and eliminate suspects until you solve the mystery - all from your kitcehn table.

What's inside the mystery box?

Each box includes carefully created documents like autopsy reports, police notes, maps, witness statements, and even physical evidence (photos, props, puzzles). Every piece is designed to feel real-to make you feel like you're solving an actual crime.

Do I need to finish the game in one sitting?

Not at all! You can pause, revisit, or tackle it over multiple evenings. Many sleuths turn it into a multiple-day or group event- it's all about your pace and style.

Are these games suitable for one person or groups?

They're perfect for solo sleuths or for small groups and date nights. We've seen everything from solo detectives to full family teams working through clues together.

Do I need internet access or a phone to play?

The investigation happens offline with printed evidence. There is a QR in the instruction pamphlet linked to online game hints to help but it is not necessary to aid in solving the crime.

What if I get stuck?

Each game has a Game Hints section on our website with spoiler free guidance to help nudge you closer to the truth- without giving it all away.

Do the boxes connect or stand alone?

Each case is standalone. You can start with any box without needing a previous one. However, they all exist within the "My Sleuthing Addiction" Universe- so you may catch easter eggs if you play them all.

What Age Is the Murder Mystery Game Best For?

Our murder mystery box is designed for ages 14 and up. While the case revolves around a fictional violent crime, the content avoids graphic descriptions to keep the experience engaging yet family-friendly. Teens and adults alike will enjoy unraveling clues, solving puzzles, and stepping into the role of detective — all without heavy or disturbing details. It’s the perfect mix of true crime-inspired storytelling and mystery-solving fun!

When Will My Murder Mystery Game Box Ship?

Once you place your order, your murder mystery box will ship within 10 days. Each box is carefully packed to include all the evidence, case files, and immersive details that make your sleuthing experience unforgettable. You'll receive tracking information as soon as it’s on its way, so you can start your investigation as soon as it hits your doorstep!

Still curious?

Check out our current case file » and see what it’s like to investigate a mystery from your own home.